Tourexpi
There are moments when taking a position becomes necessary. With Saxony-Anhalt electing a new state parliament on 6 September, Günter Ihlau and Dr Wolfgang Isenberg examine an area of politics that rarely attracts the same attention as migration, education or public broadcasting: tourism.
Their essay, “Das Land, das wir den Gästen zeigen” – “The country we show our guests” – takes statements by AfD politicians on tourism, history and national identity as its starting point. Hans-Thomas Tillschneider, the AfD parliamentary group’s spokesman for education, culture and science in Saxony-Anhalt, has called for the state to develop what he describes as “Volksbildungstourismus” – tourism serving popular education – under the banner #deutschdenken. Saxony-Anhalt, he argues, should become a “place of longing for all German patriots”.
For Ihlau and Isenberg, this raises a question extending far beyond destination marketing: who decides which stories a country tells about itself, what constitutes a sense of home and belonging, and what conclusions visitors are expected to draw from history?
When travel becomes identity politics
For a long time, the AfD’s tourism policy appeared relatively conventional. When Sebastian Münzenmaier became chairman of the German Bundestag’s Tourism Committee in 2018, the appointment was controversial, but much of the subsequent parliamentary work concerned familiar industry issues such as SMEs, infrastructure, competitiveness, digitalisation and bureaucracy.
According to the authors, a shift became more apparent later. In 2023, AfD tourism politicians at federal and state level argued that strong domestic tourism should not only support regional economic value creation but also “create identity”.
Saxony-Anhalt provides a particularly clear example. Under the #deutschdenken concept, tourism is linked to German history, national identity, language and culture. Tillschneider has described existing cultural tourism as “nationally and historically sterile” and advocated giving greater prominence to historical sites according to their importance for German identity.
Ihlau and Isenberg do not object to presenting German history. Their criticism begins where historical events and places are deliberately selected and connected in order to support a predetermined concept of national identity.
History should leave room for judgement
The proposed “Straße des Deutschen Reiches”, or “Road of the German Reich”, illustrates the distinction. The authors stress that a historical tourist route is not problematic in itself. Themed routes are a well-established tourism instrument, linking destinations and bringing visitors to smaller towns and rural areas.
The decisive issue, they argue, is the narrative connecting those places. According to Tillschneider, the route would link locations where German identity was shaped and would explicitly form part of the #deutschdenken concept.
The Bauhaus provides a contrasting example. Founded in Germany, it became a global cultural phenomenon without losing its German origins. Its ideas crossed borders, and its international significance is today an important part of Dessau’s appeal as a destination.
The authors cite Reinhard Meyer, President of the German Tourism Association, who sees eastern Germany’s tourism strength precisely in internationally recognised cultural attractions such as the Bauhaus, the Luther sites and UNESCO World Heritage properties.
Tourism itself reflects an international society
The debate also has an immediate economic dimension. Tourism depends on international visitors, but increasingly also on an international workforce.
According to figures cited by Ihlau and Isenberg, foreign nationals now account for 44.5 percent of employees subject to social security contributions in Germany’s hospitality sector. In food and beverage services the share reaches 47.8 percent, rising to 54.6 percent in food-led restaurants.
For the authors, these figures describe everyday reality rather than an abstract integration debate. People from different countries work in hotel kitchens, at reception desks and in restaurants, serve regional dishes and German wines and explain destinations to visitors.
Their argument is that belonging therefore cannot be understood solely in terms of origin. It also develops through people living, working and sharing experiences together.
Climate, landscapes and the danger of simple answers
The essay also examines the relationship between tourism, climate policy and landscape protection. Wind turbines alter landscapes, the authors acknowledge, but this does not automatically mean that renewable energy destroys landscapes or damages tourism.
Landscapes have always changed. Vineyards themselves are cultural landscapes, while reservoirs, roads, cable cars and tourism infrastructure have all transformed places that are subsequently marketed as landscapes worth protecting.
The political challenge, according to Ihlau and Isenberg, is therefore to balance competing interests: how much change can a landscape absorb, what should be preserved and who should bear the costs? They make a similar argument about climate policy, acknowledging that travel must remain affordable and that bureaucracy or poorly designed sustainability requirements can impose burdens on tourism businesses.
Their criticism is directed at reducing such complex conflicts to binary choices – landscape versus wind energy, climate protection versus freedom to travel, tradition versus “wokeness”, or the familiar versus the foreign.
Tourism thrives on different perspectives
At the heart of the essay is a broader argument about democracy. A resident sees a destination differently from a visitor, a hotelier differently from a conservationist and a hiker differently from an energy planner. Several perspectives can be legitimate at the same time without any single one representing the whole picture.
For Ihlau and Isenberg, democratic politics must ultimately make decisions, but those decisions are not improved by eliminating disagreement beforehand. They require competing interests to be recognised, consequences considered and choices explained.
The same principle applies to history. Governments can support museums, develop destinations, establish priorities and promote historical education. But, the authors argue, they should not determine in advance what political conclusion visitors are expected to reach from their encounter with history.
What kind of country do we want to be?
No single tourist route, wind turbine or debate about the Bauhaus determines the future of democracy. Taken together, however, Ihlau and Isenberg see these disputes as evidence of fundamentally different ideas about how society should deal with history, identity, diversity and change.
Their criticism is not directed against a sense of home, German history or the desire to shape social change. It is directed against what they regard as an attempt to create an increasingly unambiguous political order in which belonging is more narrowly defined and history is organised around a desired identity.
For the authors, tourism is therefore anything but a sideshow in this debate. Travel depends on encounters with what is unfamiliar, on different perspectives and on experiences whose outcome is not predetermined.
Their conclusion is correspondingly clear: a government may build roads, support museums, develop destinations, install signs and finance tourism campaigns. But it should not seek to determine what people are supposed to think at the end of their journey.
The authors
Günter Ihlau is a board member of the Center for Innovation & Sustainability in Tourism (c.i.s.t) and Chairman of the Cultural Tourism Working Group at the German Travel Association (DRV). He previously served, among other positions, as Director of International Relations at TUI AG and coordinator of TUI AG’s Leisure and Tourism think tank, and spent more than 15 years working in tourism destinations.
Dr Wolfgang Isenberg is Chairman of the Political Advisory Board for Tourism in North Rhine-Westphalia. His previous roles include Director of the Thomas Morus Academy, lecturer and coordinator of TUI AG’s Leisure and Tourism think tank.
Image Credit: © AI generated illustration with material courtesy of Tourexpi
The most interesting news
Turkish Airlines launches Chengdu flights, expanding its China network
Three weekly Boeing 787-9 services connect Istanbul with western China's major business and tourism hub, opening new travel opportunities between Türkiye and Sichuan province
Trinity Airways offers discounted flights between Taiwan and South Korea
The airline formerly known as T'way Air launches promotional fares across seven routes as it develops its new Selective Service Carrier strategy
Bangkok Illuminates the Chao Phraya with Month-Long Light Festival
Vijit Chao Phraya 2026 transforms 19 riverside locations with projections, drone displays and cultural performances from 13 November to 13 December
Southeast Asian travelers discover new destinations in Japan, China and South Korea
Traveloka booking data reveals growing interest in Fukuoka, Jeju and lesser-known Chinese cities as travelers explore alternatives to established East Asian tourism hubs
Lufthansa receives 700th Airbus as new A350-1000 flagship prepares for Tokyo debut
The aircraft marks 50 years of cooperation with Airbus and introduces Lufthansa’s latest Allegris cabins and Starlink-powered Wi-Fi on long-haul flights
Thailand expands Balkan tourism links with new Sofia–Phuket flights
A new direct service from Bulgaria and a Romanian travel trade initiative aim to increase visitor arrivals and promote multi-destination holidays along Thailand’s Andaman coast
Marella Cruises strengthens UK travel trade support with two appointments
TUI’s cruise brand introduces its first dedicated Key Account Manager and appoints a new Trade Training Manager to expand sales support and product training for travel agents
Waldorf Astoria plans to nearly triple branded residences portfolio by 2030
Hilton targets 34 residential properties worldwide, with new developments in Mexico, the Caribbean, Europe and Asia reflecting growing demand for luxury homes with hotel services
WTTC welcomes EU tourism strategy but calls for faster action on travel barriers
The global tourism body supports the European Commission’s new framework for sustainable growth while urging progress on border procedures, investment, digitalisation and workforce development
Jakarta to host major hospitality investment conference in January 2027
The 10th Hospitality Indonesia Conference will bring together more than 500 industry executives to discuss hotel investment, sustainable development, revenue management and travel technology
Dusit opens two hotels in Yangon, combining colonial heritage with modern hospitality
Thailand’s Dusit International takes over the historic Strand Hotel and introduces its ASAI lifestyle brand in Myanmar’s largest city
IHG resorts in Indonesia launch hospitality leadership programme for local graduates
Hotel Indigo and Holiday Inn Resort Bintan Lagoi Beach introduce a fully funded two-year training initiative combining practical experience with international certification
Spain’s tourism workforce exceeds 3.25 million as employment rises 5.4%
Tourism added more than 166,000 jobs in the third quarter of 2026, while permanent contracts and international employment continued to grow
Agoda survey finds growing demand for all-in-one travel booking across Asia
The 2027 Asia Travel Pulse shows that 61% of surveyed travellers are open to booking entire trips on one platform, while payment preferences and language support differ significantly between markets
Seabourn Introduces Caribbean-Inspired Culinary Experiences Across Its Voyages
New dining concepts, regional rum cocktails and beachside experiences will connect guests aboard Seabourn Ovation and Seabourn Quest with Caribbean food traditions
Malaysia to Host Cruise Industry Leaders at Seatrade Cruise Asia 2026
More than 18 cruise line brands and delegates from over 30 countries will gather in Kuala Lumpur to discuss Asia’s cruise growth, emerging source markets and new opportunities
Sofitel Legend and UNESCO Partner to Preserve Cultural Heritage Through Travel
The global partnership begins in Hanoi with cultural experiences connecting luxury hotel guests to local artisans, traditions and historic sites
Qatar Airways Expands Pre-Order Dining to Medium-Haul Premium Flights
First and Business Class passengers can now select their main courses before departure on flights lasting two hours or more
TUI Blue Expands with Eight New Hotels in Egypt and Europe
Five properties in Egypt and three in Bulgaria, Croatia and Portugal will join the portfolio between 2027 and 2029
Virgin Australia expands Boeing 737 maintenance partnership with Delta TechOps
Five-year agreement covers component support for more than 100 aircraft, strengthening Delta's aviation maintenance business across the Asia-Pacific region
CMT Stuttgart 2027 to introduce public voting for tourism films
The international tourism film competition The Golden City Gate will allow visitors to rate entries for the first time, with screenings taking place throughout the travel fair




